Practical Management of the Susceptible Mare

 

 

Introduction
This presentation will neither be a review of ALL possible approaches to the management of the susceptible mare NOR a review of treatments for endometritis such as

  • systemic antibiotics
  • intrauterine plasma
  • antiseptic intrauterine agents
  • minimum contamination techniques

A more extensive account of the aetiology, pathogenesis and treatment of endometritis in the mare can be found at the end of this lecture; diagnostic aspects have been covered in the first lecture. The presentation here will focus on a personal approach to the practical problem of management of the susceptible mare which the author has found to work well in practice.

It is important to remember that the underlying aetiology of the specific cause of endometritis determines the type of treatment to be used.

Recently, the following categorisation of endometritis has been introduced:

  • Sexually transmitted diseases
  • chronic infectious endometritis
  • persistent mating-induced endometritis (delay in uterine clearance)
  • chronic degenerative endometrosis (degenerative fibrosis)

 

The objective of the veterinary surgeon and stud farm owner/ manager should be to produce the maximum number of live, healthy foals from mares mated during the previous season. We could add 'as early as possible' to this in many breeding programmes.

One of the main obstacles to this goal is the mare which is susceptible to recurrent acute endometritis following mating.

 

Mares with Acute Endometritis

  • Endometrial culture
  • Endometrial cytology
  • Endometrial histology
  • Ultrasonography

All the above are used to identify mares with acute endometritis, but in certain circumstances detection of the susceptible mare can be difficult.

Detection of the Susceptible Mare: Problems

In the mare with subclinical endometritis there may only be subtle changes in the uterine environment, not readily detected by current diagnostic procedures.

Many mares show no signs of inflammation before mating, but will fail to resolve the inevitable endometritis which follows mating.

 

How can these mares be detected and subsequently managed to maximise their reproductive potential?

Management of the Susceptible Mare: Detection

  • Response to bacterial challenge has been used in a research setting
  • History is perhaps the most useful indicator of a susceptible mare in practice.
  • Demonstration of clearance failure has been used again in a research setting
  • Recently use of the ultrasound to detect uterine luminal fluid has also proved useful to identify mares with a clearance problem.


Fluid in uterus on ultra sound scan

 

In many cases, the uterine luminal fluid which accumulates before mating is sterile and contains no neutrophils (Pycock and Newcombe 1996a). The importance of these sterile fluid accumulations is that, although initially sterile, the fluid may act as a culture medium for bacteria which gain entry to the uterus at mating and may be spermicidal (McKinnon et al 1993). Comparison with traditional methods for diagnosing endometritis (vaginascopic examination; bacterial culture; cytology; rectal palpation and biopsy) supports the statement that ultrasonographic detection of uterine fluid accumulation is faster than conventional techniques and avoids the problems of inadvertently contaminating the uterus. It can still be difficult to interpret the results as although in almost all cases if no fluid is detected than no neutrophils were found on a smear (Pycock and Newcombe 1996a), rarely this was not the case with neutrophils being found in the absence of detectable fluid.

Uterine Defence Mechanisms

With the recognition that physical clearance of uterine fluid was the critical factor in the defence against persistent uterine infection, it was a logical conclusion that any impairment of this function rendered a mare susceptible to persistent endometritis (Troedsson and Liu 1991).

I do not believe that impaired mechanical clearance is an immunological problem and for this reason I think the term "susceptible" mare rather than "immune incompetent" mare may be more appropriate for these mares with a clearance problem. The concept of susceptibility to endometritis was initially introduced by Farrelly and Mullaney (1964) and Hughes et al (1966). Subsequently, the idea was developed further by Hughes and Loy (1969) and Peterson, McFeely and David (1969) and formed the basis of the present-day concept of the "susceptible" mare. Of course, not all mares have a clearance problem and, in those mares, some immune defect is likely to be involved and here "immune-incompetent" is an appropriate term.

Management of the Susceptible Mare

Ultrasound evaluation of the uterus for the detection of intraluminal uterine fluid

Pre-Mating Intraluminal Fluid: Significance ?

Mares with uterine fluid detected during a pre-breeding examination have a reduced pregnancy rate (Pycock and Newcombe 1996a)

 

The amount of fluid which should be considered significant is not clear and it may be that quantity is more important than nature. This is particularly true of fluid appearing during oestrus. The significance depends to some extent on when during oestrus the fluid is observed: fluid detected early in oestrus may have disappeared when the mare is further advanced in oestrus and the cervix relaxes more. Generally if there is more than one centimetre of fluid during oestrus some attempt shopuld be made to remove this prior to breeding using oxytocin. If the volume is above two centimetres, the fluid may need to be drained and investigated for the presence of inflammatory cells and bacteria. The mare may then need to have a large- volume uterine lavage. Fluid in diestrus is more serious and any detectable volume nearly always indicates a problem.

Uterine Fluid

It has been suggested that fluid be graded from 1 to 3 according to the degree of echogenicity. The more echoic the fluid, the more likely the fluid is contaminated with debris including white blood cells. However, cellular fluid can appear relatively anechoic so care is needed in interpretation. Inspissated pus can be so echoic that it is overlooked. It may be that the actual appearance of the fluid and the ultrasonographic appearance are not as closely linked as once thought. Ultrasonographic appearance may relate to particle sizeand this is why the urine in the bladder can appear relatively echoic, despite being a watery liquid.

Cellular content AND particle size effect echogenicity of image

Some lucent (black) fluids have high PMN counts

SO do NOT place too much emphasis on grading fluid

Recognition of the importance of the mechanical evacuation of uterine contents accounted for the relatively recent introduction of large-volume uterine lavage as a treatment for inflammatory disorders of the mare's uterus (Asbury 1990). I have found this to be a useful therapeutic protocol in many cases.

The technique involves the mechanical suction or siphonage of 2 to 3 litres of previously warmed saline infused into the uterus via a catheter that has been retained within the cervix via a cuff. The most convenient is a large-bore (30 French) (80 cm) equine embryo flushing catheter (EUF-80; Bivona, USA).


Flushing catheter with cuff inflated in position in the mare

 

The rationale for such an approach are:

  1. The removal of accumulated uterine fluid and inflammatory debris which may interfere with neutrophil function and the efficacy of antibiotics;
  2. Stimulation of uterine contractility;
  3. Recruitment of fresh neutrophils through mechanical irritation of the endometrium;

The washings can also be inspected to provide immediate information concerning the nature of the uterine contents.

Undoubtedly large volume lavage is beneficial in many cases, particularly the mare with a relatively large (above 2 cm depth) accumulation of fluid after breeding. Few controlled studies on pregnancy rates have been conducted. In addition, the process is time-consuming and there is the possibility of further contamination of the uterus by passage of a drainage tube.

For optimal practical management, the ideal method of treatment will involve the use of a non-invasive technique with early and complete elimination of any intrauterine fluid. This can be performed more realistically in practice when it may be difficult to justify the time needed to large-volume lavage the uterus.

Oxytocin, because of its ecbolic effect, was first suggested as a possible treatment for mares susceptible to persistent acute endometritis by Allen (1991). It is interesting to speculate why it was only relatively recently that a such a familiar drug as oxytocin was suggested as a treatment for endometritis:

Of course, the importance of fluid accumulation in the aetiology of persistent acute endometritis had to be recognised. Even when this was established, many people believed oxytocin would only induce uterine contractions after foaling. Other people believed it would cause severe colic when given as an intravenous bolus. A third concern was that there would be an adverse effect on gamete transport. The initial work of Allen (1991) and subsequent clinical experience (Pycock 1994a; Pycock and Newcombe 1996b) have allayed all these fears.

The latter authors recently reported the following management protocol as useful in the highly susceptible mare (i.e. a mare which from past experience/history is known to produce a large amount (several centimetres depth) of luminal fluid after mating). It should be remembered that this approach is being suggested as part of the management of the susceptible mare and is not suggested as a routine for all mares. The protocol is as follows:

* A single breeding must be arranged 1,2 or even 3 days before the anticipated time of ovulation. It is my experience that most stallion spermatozoa are viable at least 48-72 hours after mating and this is also supported by Umphenour, Sprinkle and Murphy (1993). In any case records based on previous early pregnancy examinations will soon indicate if the semen from a particular stallion is not viable after 48 hours. This early mating allows more time for drainage of fluid via an open oestrous cervix and also utilises the natural resistance of the tract to inflammation during oestrus. In the author's opinion, treatment for endometritis is ideally performed on the day before, or the day of, ovulation. Progesterone concentrations rise rapid ly in the mare and any post-ovulation treatment has an increased risk of uterine contamination. In addition, uterine fluid is less likely to drain if the cervix is beginning to close.

* Ultrasound examination of the uterus 3-12 hours after mating is performed to assess the amount and echogenicity of any intrauterine fluid. This examination and treatment of mares very soon after mating before the bacteria have been long in a logarithmic growth phase is important for the susceptible mare. Treatment has been successful as early as 2 hours after mating.

* Intravenous administration of 25 i.u. oxytocin and, with scrupulous attention to cleanliness, digital dilation of the cervix in mares that exhibit uterine fluid; oxytocin is less effective at causing fluid drainage once the mare has ovulated. This is another reason for ideally treating the susceptible mare before ovulation.

* After 20 minutes the mare should be re-examined and any fluid pooling in the vagina removed;

* Infusion of a low volume of water-soluble broad-spectrum antibiotics (neomycin (1g), polymixin B (40,000 i.u.), furaltadone (600mg) and 3g crystalline benzylpenicillin (Utrin Wash, Univet Ltd., Wedgwood Road, Bicester) dissolved in 20ml of sterile water) into the uterus via a sterile irrigation catheter. I use a low volume of antibiotic solution as, if these mares have a drainage problem, it seems logical to use the minimum effective volume. It is my experience that with larger volumes (above 100 ml) some of the solution is lost via cervical reflux.

* The mare is re-examined the following day and oxytocin treatment repeated if fluid is still present. Only rarely will a second infusion of antibiotics or lavage procedure be performed due to the risk of uterine contamination.

Obviously it was impossible to be certain of the importance of each component of the management protocol, but the results did indicate the benefit of this management regime in mares in which subfertility is associated with intraluminal fluid. In some mares the incorporation of large-volume lavage will be beneficial. These protocols are difficult to apply in practice where stud farms are not being visited every day and is, therefore, best reserved for the highly susceptible mare. Susceptibility to endometritis is not an absolute state: failure of the defence mechanisms only needs to be of the degree necessary to slow the process of clearance past a critical point. As many stud farms are visited on an every other day basis for routine reproductive work, treatment schedules should be based round these visits.

Therefore, the need is for a single effective post-mating treatment for endometritis.

Preliminary results from the use of oxytocin to assist uterine clearance appeared to represent an advancement in the management of susceptible mares. In addition current research (LeBlanc et al 1994) concluded that oxytocin enhances uterine clearance of radiocolloid and may be useful for treating mares exhibiting impaired uterine clearance.

As a further evaluation, a large controlled study was designed to critically evaluate the efficacy of intrauterine antibiotics or intravenous oxytocin treatments, alone or in combination, for the management of subfertility caused by persistent endometritis (Pycock 1994b). By using a large number of mares in normal clinical practice, the use of an endometritis model was avoided.

The following specific hypothesis was tested: When administered after mating, intrauterine antibiotics and intravenous oxytocin, either alone or in combination, could improve the pregnancy rate of mares.

Materials and Methods:
During the 1993 breeding season, maiden, barren and lactating mares of Thoroughbred (n=245), hunter (n=115), and pony (n=20) types aged 3-23 years were allocated into four groups on a strict rotational basis. Group 1 mares were controls. Group 2 mares had a single post-mating infusion of broad- spectrum, water-soluble antibiotics (Utrin wash, as above). Group 3 mares were given a single intravenous injection of 25 i.u. oxytocin. Group 4 mares were given an intravenous injection of oxytocin followed by intrauterine antibiotic infusion. The mares were scanned for pregnancy on days 14 and 30 after mating.

Summary of Results:

In group 1 (non-treated) mares, more fluid accumulated in the uterine lumen after mating, which was the most likely reason for the reduced pregnancy rates in this group. The pregnancy rates were highest in mares which recei ved the combination of antibiotics and oxytocin.


Pregnacy rates folowing different intrauterine treatments

 

Discussion and Conclusion: Treatments which either cause the elimination of, or reduce the production, of intrauterine fluid, are useful in the management of post- mating endometritis in the mare. As pregnancy rates were highest in mares given the combined treatment, this suggested two different modes of action, namely antibacterial activity and fluid drainage, which were additively helpful.

Intrauterine antibiotic therapy has been the traditional approach to treating endometritis and, therefore, it was considered important to include in the clinical study. I have not seen a resistance or superinfection problem with this particular combination reported here.

Antibacterial activity may possibly be linked to reduction of intraluminal fluid since, in those mares that were treated with oxytocin alone, some bacteria remained within the uterine lumen and presumably the inflammatory efects of these bacteria caused further fluid production and accumulation.

 

The obvious conclusion from the study is that the use of oxytocin and antibiotic intrauterine infusions is effective in increasing pregnancy rates and subsequent foaling rates in mares. This conclusion was supported by the results of a second trial involving a further 900 mares (Pycock and newcombe 1996b).

From this it is necessary to ask the question "is it desirable to treat every mare routinely after mating regardless of the clinical history?"

The answer must be no, since treatment should be restricted to those mares which would benefit.

It may be useful to use ultrasonographic examination of the uterus to identify those mares with uterine fluid after mating and only treat these mares.

Another approach that appeared useful was to "target" categories of mares which benefitted most from treatment in terms of pregnancy rate.This study indicated two such categories:

A) Old mares (over the age of 12);

B) Mares mated at the first oestrus post-partum.

Other compounds were, and still are, infused into the uterus of mares, based on the research findings of the seventies and eighties which emphasised the immunological aspects of the uterine defence mechanisms against acute endometritis. Early suspicions that susceptible mares were deficient in uterine immunoglobulins led to the therapeutic use of colostrum, an abundant source of immunoglobulins, infused into the uterus (Dewes 1980). However, later work (Asbury et al 1980; Mitchell et al 1982) reported that concentrations of immunoglo bulins were greater in susceptible mares.

A reported deficiency of opsonin (Asbury 1984) led to the use of intrauterine plasma as a source of opsonins. Studies following its use have indicated an improvement of fertility (Asbury 1984; Pascoe 1994). Both authors suggested that the plasma had an enhancing efect on phagocytosis by uterine neutrophils. Adams and Ginther (1989), in a study which included control groups of mares, found that intrauterine plasma was not efficacious in treating endometritis since there was no improvement in pregnancy rates. Troedsson et al (1992) suggested that plasma treatment might only benefit certain susceptible mares. This latter point was also alluded to recently by Pascoe (1994) who, whilst remaining enthusiastic about the use of plasma in the management of immune-incompetent mares, conceded that this may only apply to mares without a mechanical clearance problem. Consequently I use plasma only in mares which repeatedly fail to become pregnant, but have no history of fluid accumulation.

Ideally, one should make an accurate diagnosis that a mare has a clearance problem as oxytocin therapy is only likely to be beneficial in such mares. Detection of intraluminal fluid is the best practical method. Scintigraphic and other methods based on charcoal clearance are difficult to apply in the majority of practice-type situations.

 

SUMMARY: PRACTICAL MANAGEMENT OF THE SUSCEPTIBLE MARE

Use ultrasound evaluation of the uterus for detection of intraluminal uterine fluid, in addition to conventional techniques of endometrial cytology and bacteriology, before mating.

Recent work has shown that, although initially sterile and free of neutrophils, mares with uterine fluid accumulation before mating have a reduced pregnancy rate when no treatment is performed (Pycock and Newcombe 1996a). If more than 2cm fluid are detected, administer 3 ml oxytocin as an intravenous bolus. Confirm that the fluid has gone at the next ultrasound examination. If intraluminal fluid is still visible, repeat the dose of oxytocin and, possibly, digitally dilate the cervix also.

Ensure good management techniques at all times.

Particular regard should be paid to:

A) Attention to Hygiene:

    i) at mating
       a) use a tail bandage;
       b) wash the mare's vulva and perineal area with clean water, ideally from a spray nozzle which avoids the need for buckets;

    ii) at foaling: examine all mares post partum for the presence of trauma which might compromise the physical barriers to uterine contamination;

    iii) at gynaecological examinations: examinations per vagina should be performed as aseptically as possible.

B) Correct timing of mating: This should ensure the minimal number of matings.

C) Correction of any conformational defects.

 

Adoption of a routine post-mating treatment policy

i) Unable to detect the mare which needs post-mating treatment

ii) History important

iii) The most successful cycle on which to breed old barren mares is the first (NOT the first cycle of the breeding season which is best avoided in older mares, but the first cycle on which the mare is bred

In any case evaluation of the uterus post-breeding is a crucial time to assess the uterus of all mares and too many clincialns fail to evaluate the uterus post-breeding.

I have not adopted a routine post-mating treatment policy. However, in my daily routine, I assume that most multiparous mares are at risk for either clinical or subclinical endometritis following insemination, be it natural or artificial. This view is also held by Australian colleagues who claim increased pregnancy rates and subsequent foaling rates through adoption of a routine post-mating treatment (Pascoe, personal communication; Pascoe 1994). At a recent conference on equine endometritis, Zent (1993) recently reported that, of 4000 brood mares under the care of members of his Kentucky veterinary practice, all except maiden mares were routinely given at least one post-mating intrauterine antibiotic infusion. He believed this treatment had improved pregnancy rates, without the development of a resistance problem or an increased incidence of fungal endometritis. Other large veterinary practices involved in stud medicine do not use post-mating treatment to anything like this extent. This could be for two reasons:

A) If a large percentage of the mares at the stud farm are young mares or mares with no history of breeding problems, then the pregnancy rate without any treatment is likely to be high, as few of the mares will be susceptible mares. Consequently, post-mating treatment would have little observable benefit.

B) If mares are never mated under any circumstances until endometrial swab and smear results are negative and no uterine luminal fluid is present on ultrasound examination, then this will also select for a high pregnancy rate in the absence of post-mating treatment.

However, if old mares, barren mares or mares with a history of being difficult to get in foal make up a large percentage of the brood mare population at a particular stud farm, then adoption of a routine post-mating treatment regime will probably increase pregnancy rates. I base my decision on which treatment to adopt on history and clinical findings including ultrasonographic evaluation of the uterus after mating. This ultrasound examination of the uterus is very important and it is imperative it is performed in every brood mare after mating. If the history suggests that the mare is highly susceptible to persistent endometritis i.e. will develop significant amounts of intrauterine luminal fluid after mating, then I consider adopting the protocol of early mating, intrauterine antibiotics and oxytocin outlined earlier. Additionally uterine lavage may be used on one or, rarely, two occasions.

If there is no indication of susceptibility to endometritis, my treatment depends on the ultrasonographic findings. If no uterine fluid is present, intrauterine antibiotics alone are infused if the mare is believed to be at risk for subclinical endometritis. If any uterine fluid is present, the mare is given 25 i.u. of oxytocin as an intravenous bolus and re-examined 30 minutes later when intrauterine antibiotics are infused. I leave 2 x 3ml of oxytocin to be given by the stud farm personnel that evening and again in the morning. This is by the intramuscular route.

In some mares, the slower release of prostaglandin (cloprostenol 500mcg IM) may be useful also.

The mare is re-examined usually 2 days later and the uterus re-examined for fluid. Further oxytocin treatment is given as required. Only in mares with a very poor history and/or where significant fluid remains in the uterus is a second infusion of intrauterine antibiotics given. I am not enthusiastic about repeated intrauterine antibiotic infusions due to the possibility of uterine contamination. Recent work from our clinic has indicated the usefulness of intramuscular administration of a third-generation cephalosporin for the treatment of pyometra. This product may also be useful as a follow-up intramuscular treatment after the initial intrauterine treatment, but this remains to be evaluated.

An important concept that would appear important is to treat in relation to breeding and not wait for ovulation

My final decision to adopt a routine post-mating treatment of mares believed to be at risk of persistent acute endometritis is dependent on balancing cost and time against benefits to the breeder. The results of published clinical studies (Pascoe 1994; Pycock 1994b) and many breeding seasons field experience with large numbers of mares have demonstrated the effectiveness of a single post-mating treatment to combat endometritis. This has certainly been the case in the mares with which I have been involved.

Against this demonstrable improvement in pregnancy rate, it must be examined if there is any reason, apart from the economic reason, not to routinely treat all mares after mating:

Certainly management standards must not fall. Post-mating treatment should not be seen as a means of getting away with poor management.

No bacterial resistance problems or increase in fungal endometritis must be apparent with the intrauterine antibiotics used.

Some questions remain unanswered and a source of debate amongst clinicians.

For example, Hearn (1993) recently voiced the concern that the early embryonic/foetal loss rate of susceptible mares with endometritis who receive aggressive post-mating therapy will be much higher despite the temporary improvement in uterine environment. This was not supported by the clinical study reported here, perhaps because only a single post-mating treat ment was performed. Undoubtedly the live foal-rate of mares which are extensively treated post-breeding is less than in young, genitally-healthy mares., However, often susceptible mares are old and frequently when uterine biopsy results are available, these often confim degenerative changes within the endometrium. Consequently one's live-foal rate expectations are lower in these mares in any case. This is not a reason to not treat mares post-mating in my opinion. Of course one should optimise the chances for conception by the methods discussed above and in other papers, but even when all these techniques of management, pre-mating examination etc. are applied, the susceptible mare should still be treated post- mating.

One question in particular remains less easy to address:

At what point should the susceptible mare be mated and when should she be treated and either short cycled or mated at the next natural oestrus?

This must be a matter of clinical experience based on history, findings of clinical and laboratory examinations and past results. Some clinicans remain cautious whereas others will adopt a "mate at all costs" policy with aggressive post-mating treatment. Hopefully this paper will allow a rational approach to the management of the susceptible mare.

 

 

REFERENCES

Allen, W.E. (1991) Investigations into the use of oxytocin for promoting uterine drainage in mares susceptible to endometritis. Vet. Rec. 127, 593-594.
Asbury, A.C. (1984) Uterine defence mechanisms in the mare: The use of intrauterine plasma in the management of endometritis. Theriogenology, 21, 387-393.
Asbury, A.C., Halliwell, R.W., Foster, G.W. and Longino, S.J. (1980) Immunoglobulins in uterine secretions of mares with differing resistance to endometritis. Theriogenology 14, 299- 308.
Dewes, H.F. (1980) Preliminary observations on the use of colostrum as an intrauterine infusion in Thoroughbred mares. New Zealand vet. J. 28, 7-8.
Farrelly, B.Y. and Mullaney, P.E. (1964) Cervical and uterine infections in thoroughbred mares. Irish vet. J. 18, 210-212.
Hearn, P. (1993) The relationship of uterine inflammation to fertility. Proc. Soc. Theriogenology. pp 139-147.
Hughes, J.P. and Loy, R.G. (1969) Investigations on the effect of intrauterine inoculations of Streptococcus zooepidemicus in the mare. Proc. 15th Ann. Conv. Am. Ass. equine Pract. pp 289-292.
Hughes, J.P., Loy, R.G., Asbury, A.C. and Burd, H.G. (1966) The occurrence of Pseudomonas in the reproductive tract of mares and its effect on fertility. Cornell Vet. 56, 595-610.
LeBlanc, M.M., Neuwirth, L., Mauragis, D., Klapstein, E. and Tran, T. (1994) Oxytocin enhances clearance of radiocolloid from the uterine lumen of reproductively normal mares and mares susceptible to endometritis. Equine vet. J. 26, 279-282.
McKinnon, A.O., Voss, J.L., Squires, E.L. and Carnevale, E.M. (1993) Diagnostic ultrasonography. In: Equine reproduction. Eds: A.O. McKinnon and J.L. Voss. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger. pp 266-302.
Mitchell, G., Liu, I.K.M., Perryman, L.E., Stabenfeldt, G.H. and Hughes, J.P. (1982) Preferential production and secretion of immunoglobulins by the equine endometrium - a mucosal immune system. J. Reprod. Fert., Suppl. 32, 161-168.
Pascoe, D.R. (1994) The effect of adding autologous plasma to an intrauterine antibiotic therapy post breeding on pregnancy rates in mares. Proc. Sixth International Symposium on Equine Reproduction, Brazil. pp 137-138.
Peterson, F.B., McFeely, R.A. and David, J.S.E. (1969) Studies on the pathogenesis of endometritis in the mare. Proc. 15th Ann. Conv. Am. Ass. equine Pract. pp 279-288.
Pycock, J.F. (1994a) A new approach to treatment of endometritis. Equine vet.Educ.6, 36-38.
Pycock, J.F. (1994b) Assessment of oxytocin and intrauterine antibiotics on intrauterine fluid and pregnancy rates in the mare. Proc. 40th Ann. Conv. Am. Ass. equine Pract.
Pycock, J.F. and Newcombe, J.R. (1996a) The relationship between intraluminal uterine fluid, endometritis and pregnancy rate in the mare. Equine Pract. 18, 19-22.
Pycock, J.F. and Newcombe, J. R. (1996b) Assessment of the effect of three treatments to remove intrauterine fluid on pregnancy rate in the mare. Veterinary Record 138, 320-323.
Ricketts, S.W. (1995) Non-venereal uterine infection. Proc. 7th equine stud medicine and artificial insemination course, Newmarket. Pub. R & W Publishing.
Troedsson, M.H.T. and Liu, I.K.M. (1991) Uterine clearance of non-antigenic markers (51- Cr) in response to a bacterial challenge in mares potentially susceptible and resistant to chronic uterine infections. J. Reprod. Fert., Suppl. 44, 283-288.
Troedsson, M.H.T., Scott, M.A. and Liu, I.K.M. (1992) Pathogenesis and treatment of chronic uterine infection. Proc. 38th Ann. Conv. Am. Ass. equine Pract. pp 595-600.
Umphenour, N.W., Sprinkle, T.A. and Murphy, H.Q. (1993) Natural service. In: Equine Reproduction. Eds. A.M. McKinnon and J.L. Voss. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia. pp 798- 808.
Zent, W. (1993) Post-ovulation intrauterine antibiotics. Proceedings of J.P. Hughes International Workshop on Equine Endometritis, summarised by W.R. Allen. Equine vet. J. 25, 192.

 

Endometritis in the Mare

Cause and Pathogenesis

Reduced fertility associated with endometritis, both acute and chronic, has been recognized for many years in broodmares. The term `endometritis' refers to the acute or chronic inflammatory changes involving the endometrium. These changes frequently occur as a result of microbial infection, but they can also be due to non-infectious causes.

Recently, the following classification system has been introduced and is useful when considering endometritis as it occurs in the horse:

  • Sexually transmitted diseases
  • chronic infectious endometritis
  • persistent mating-induced endometritis (delay in uterine clearance)
  • chronic degenerative endometrosis (degenerative fibrosis)

 

It is generally assumed that the uterine lumen of the normal fertile mare is bacteriologically sterile or may have a temporary, non-resident microflora, although bacteria have been seen in healthy uteri by scanning electron microscopy. Ricketts and Mackintosh (1987) suggested that the equine uterus may harbour obligate anaerobes as surface commensals.

The environment of the uterine lumen must be compatible with embryonic and fetal life. This presents a particular problem for the mare as a transient endometritis is an inevitable sequel to coitus. Ejaculation occurs through the dilated cervix, contaminating the uterine lumen with microorganisms and debris. Parturition and a defective perineal conformation can also result in contamination. In the normal healthy mare, the induced postcoital endometritis resolves within 24--72 hours. Microorganisms and inflammatory by-prodÂucts disappear from the uterus to leave the endometrium in a satisfactory state to receive the fertilized ovum. Timing is critical, as the embryo descends from the uterine tube into the uterine lumen about 5.5 days after ovulation. In addition to being incompatible with embryonic survival, endometritis persisting after day 4 of dioestrus also causes lysis of the corpus luteum due to premature endogenous prostaglandin release so that the mare has a shortened luteal phase. In some mares the inflammation persists; these are referred to as susceptible individuals. The concept of susceptibility to endometritis was first suggested by Farrely and Mullaney (1964), who stated that infective endometritis is essentially the failure of as individual mare to limit the uterine and cervical microflora to a non-resident type. Hughes and Loy (1969) developed this concept and confirmed that resistant mares could eliminate induced infection without treatment; susceptible mares could not. In general, reduced resistance to endometritis is associated with advancing age and multiparity. Susceptibility to endometritis is not, however, an absolute state since failure of uterine defence mechanisms need only slow the process of eliminating infection. Studies on immunoglobulins, opsonins and the functional ability of neutrophils in the uterus of susceptible mares have not confirmed the presence of an impaired immune response (see the review by Allen and Pycock, 1989). Evans et al. (1986) first suggested that reduced physical drainage may contribute to an increased susceptibility to uterine infection. The physical ability of the uterus to eliminate bacteria, inflammatory debris and fluid is now known to be a critical factor in uterine defence. Since the first description of the identification of the collection of small volumes of intra-uterine fluid using ultrasound, which could not be palpated per rectum (Ginther and Pierson, 1984), general awareness of the frequency of this abnormality has increased. The detection of uterine fluid during both oestrus and dioestrus has been reported (Allen and Pycock, 1988). Endometrial secretions and the formation of the small volume of free fluid may be associated with the same mechanism which causes normal oestral oedema. Small volumes of intrauterine fluid during oestrus do not affect pregnancy rates (Pycock and Newcombe, 1996a), but in mares that are susceptible to endometritis there is an accumulation of more fluid than in resistant mares. Intrauterine fluid during dioestrus is indicative of inflammation, and associated with subfertility, due to early embryonic death and a shortened luteal phase.

Initially, although a sterile transudate, fluid may act as a medium for bacteria which gain entry to the uterus at mating to multiply; it may also be spermicidal.

The bacterial species which cause bacterial endometritis are numerous, and can be classified as follows:

  1. contaminants and commensals;
  2. opportunist, causing an acute endometritis;
  3. venereally transmitted.

Normally, the vestibular and clitoral area has a harmless and constantly fluctuating bacterial population. In association with benign saprophytic organisms, opportunistic organisms such as Streptococcus zooepidemicus, E. coli and Staphyloccocus spp. can be found. The stallion's penis is colonized by similar organisms. S. zooepidemicus is the most commonly isolated bacterial species from acute endometritis, particularly in the initial stages. E. coli is the next most common isolate.

In addition to these opportunist pathogens, there are three bacteria which are venereally transmitted: Taylorella equigenitalis (contagious equine metritis organism, CEMO), Klebsiella pneumoniae (capsular types 1, 2 and 5) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (some strains). Symptomless carriers of both sexes allow persistence within the horse population. Carrier mares, which may or may not have shown signs of previous endometritis, harbour the organisms in the vestibular area, particularly the clitoral fossa and sinuses. Mating or gynaecological examination may result in their transfer into the uterus. Stallions may harbour the organisms over the entire surface of the penis and in the distal urethra.

Anaerobic bacteria have been isolated from the mare's uterus, with Bacteroides fragilis the most frequent. Further work is needed to assess the importance of anaerobes in endometritis.

 

Treatment of endometritis

Antibiotic Therapy
The traditional approach to treating endometritis has been the infusion of various antibiotics, dissolved or suspended in water or saline, into the uterine lumen during oestrus. The intrauterine route is preferable to systemic therapy as most acute endometritis cases are localized. Systemic treatment alone or in combination with local application is suitable in a few circumstances. Ideally, the choice of antibiotic for local treatment should be based on in vitro antibiotic sensitivity tests. However, in many cases this is not possible and a broad-spectrum combination is used. A particularly successful preparation has been a water-soluble mixture of neomycin (1g), polymyxin B (40,000 IU), furaltadone (600 mg) (Utrin Wash; Univet) and crystalline benzylpenicillin (5 mega-units) dissolved in 30 ml of sterile water and then instilled into the uterus via a sterile irrigation catheter. This is inserted through the cervix into the uterus along the index finger which has been introduced through the external os uteri. If the tip cannot be advanced once it has passed through the cervix, it may be helpful to direct the tip of the catheter downwards. The use of this extremely broad-spectrum preparation, has not resulted in superinfection with Pseudomonas spp., Klebsiella spp. or fungi. The number of infusions required depends on individual circumstances. The success of this treatment can be monitored using ultrasonography to identify the presence of intrauterine fluid. When antibiotics are combined with oxytocin (see later) a single daily treatment for three days has, in many cases, proved successful. Repeated endometrial swab/smear examinations may be used to monitor the response to therapy; however, every time the cervix is breached there is the risk of introducing more bacteria. An indwelling intrauterine device has been used which can retain a narrow-diameter infusion catheter within the cervix; however, there is a risk of ascending infection.

Since within 2 hours of breeding the spermatozoa necessary for fertilization are present within the uterine tube, and since the embryo does not descend into the uterus for about 5.5 days, mares may be treated safely from 12 hours after mating until 3 days from ovulation, providing non-irritant therapy is used. However, progesterone concentrations rise rapidly following ovulation in the mare and it is preferable to avoid treatment involving uterine interference beyond 2 days after ovulation. Both coitus and artificial insemination can be a source of uterine contamination; therefore, the successful management of susceptible mares should logically require some form of postmating therapy such as intrauterine antibiotic infusion and intravenous oxytocin.

Uterine Lavage
Uterine lavage has rightly become a popular and very useful treatment for endometritis. The technique involves the mechanical suction or siphonage of 1--2 litres of previously warmed saline infused into the uterus via a catheter that has been retained within the cervix by a cuff. The most convenient is a large-bore (30 French) (80ðcm) equine embryo flushing catheter (EUF-80; Bivona).

The rationale for such an approach are:

  1. the removal of accumulated uterine fluid and inflammatory debris which may interfere with neutrophil function and the efficacy of antibiotics;
  2. stimulation of uterine contractility;
  3. recruitment of fresh neutrophils through mechanical irritation of the endometrium.

The washings can also be inspected to provide immediate information concerning the nature of the uterine contents.

Oxytocin
The ideal method of treatment will involve the use of a non-invasive technique with early and complete elimination of any intrauterine fluid. Oxytocin stimulates uterine contractions in the cyclical and postpartum mare. Preliminary reports of its use to promote uterine drainage in mares susceptible to endometritis found that there was no adverse effect on fertility when used as an intravenous bolus of 10 IU (Allen, 1991). Subsequently, much success has been achieved with the use of 25 IU of oxytocin given as an intravenous bolus (Pycock, 1994b,c; Pycock and newcombe 1996b). No untoward effects have been noted apart from a very occasional mild and transient discomfort. Although the half-life of oxytocin has not been reported for the mare, it is likely to be between 2 and 10 minutes. In most mares the response is rapid, with fluid voided almost immediately.

The author has found the following regimen to be an effective treatment in the mare highly susceptible to endometritis, i.e. the mare that will pool much uterine fluid after mating: (1) a single mating must be arranged 2--3 days before the anticipated time of ovulation; (2) ultrasound examination of the uterus 3--12 hours after mating is used to assess the amount and echogenicity of any intrauterine fluid; (3) intravenous administration of 25 IU of oxytocin and manual dilation of the cervix in mares that exhibit intrauterine fluid; (4) infusion of a low volume of water-soluble broad-spectrum antibiotics into the uterus.

Asbury (1992) stated that there has been no corresponding improvement in the efficacy of the treatment of bacterial endometritis, despite the advances in the number and type of pharmacological agents available. Large field studies including proper controls are needed to critically evaluate therapy for endometritis. A recent clinical trial in over 1400 mares has shown that treatments with broad-spectrum antibiotic intrauterine infusions and intravenous oxytocin injection were effective in the treatment of endometritis and in the improvement of pregnancy rates (Pycock and Newcombe, 1996b).

Intrauterine Plasma and Colostrum Infusions
Plasma is a rich source of opsonin. Studies, following intrauterine infusion, have shown improvements in fertility, and it was suggested that the plasma had an enhancing effect on phagocytosis by uterine neutrophils. However, in a controlled experiment, it was not found to be efficacious in treating endometritis, and pregnancy rates were not improved (Adams and Ginther, 1989).

Colostrum is a rich source of immunoglobulins, and has been used by intrauterine infusion as a treatment. Since mares that are susceptible to endometritis do not possess a quantitative deficiency of immunoglobulins, it is questionable if such treatment should be used. In addition, transfer of infectious agents is also possible.

Curettage
Improved fertility after endometrial curettage of barren mares has been reported. This has involved the use of mechanical and chemical agents (namely povidone--iodine and kerosene).

Hormonal Therapy
Exogenous oestrogens have been used as a treatment of endometritis and have been shown to enhance natural uterine defence mechanisms. Repeated treatment with PGF2alpha increases the frequency of the follicular phases thus allowing intrauterine therapy to be used more readily. In addition, it also reduces the duration of the luteal phase where progesterone increases the susceptibility to infection.

Prevention
Good management also plays a vital role in the control and prevention of infectious infertility. Attention to hygiene at mating by using a tail bandage and washing the mare's vulva and perineal area with clean water (ideally from a spray nozzle which avoids the need for buckets) and limiting the number of matings are particularly important. Minimal contamination techniques in which semen extender containing antibiotics is infused into the uterus immediately before mating may be helpful. Good hygiene at foaling is also essential and all mares should be thoroughly examined postpartum for the presence of trauma which might compromise the physical barriers to uterine contamination. Gynaecological examinations, particularly of the vagina, should be performed as aseptically as possible. Since air in the vagina can cause irritation of the mucosa it should be expelled by applying downward pressure with the hand through the rectal wall.

Treatment of venereal infections
Any mare that is suspected of having a venereal infection must not be mated. In the case of clitoral or vestibular infections, topical treatment is used. This involves thorough cleaning with chlorhexidine surgical scrub followed by the application of 0.2% nitrofurazone ointment (T. equigenitalis), 0.3% gentamicin cream (K. pneumoniae) or silver nitrate and gentamicin cream (P. aeruginosa). These pathogens, particularly P. aeruginosa, are difficult to eliminate from the clitoris, hence clitoral sinusectomy or clitorectomy may have to be used in refractory cases. A broth culture containing a mixture of growing organisms prepared from the normal clitÂoral flora can suppress venereal pathogens in some cases. Evidence for the successful elimination of infection is based on three negative sets of clitoral and endometrial swabs, taken at weekly intervals.

Fungal infections
Mycotic endometritis is not as common as that of bacteriological origin, but recognition of a fungus as the causal agent is important since commonly used intrauterine antibiotic therapy is ineffective. In cases of fungal endometritis, mares may have a history of normal or abnormal oestrous cycles, they may be anoestrus or barren, and they may have had a recent abortion or a fetal membrane retention; in addition there may be a history of repeated intraÂuterine antibiotic therapy. Yeasts more frequently cause endometritis than moulds; Candida albicans is the most common isolate.

Diagnosis
This is based upon the presence of fungal elements and inflammatory cells in endometrial smears. In addition, yeasts can also be identified following staining with `Diff-Kwik' (American Hospital Supplies) using a magnification of 400. Fungal elements are more readily identified in endometrial biopsies following staining with Gomori's methenamine silver or periodic acid--Schiff (PAS).

Successful culture of endometrial smears for fungi can be difficult because the organisms may be present in low numbers, and furthermore they require a long incubation period. For example, studies in Florida, USA, where C. albicans infection is very common, have shown that despite the identification of yeast buds in stained smears in the presence of neutrophils, the organism was frequently not detected following culture.

Treatment
These infections are very difficult to treat. Intra-uterine lavage with 2--3 litres of warm saline, followed by antimycotic preparations such as povidone--iodine (1--2% solution daily for 5 days); nystatin (200000--500000 units daily for 5 days) or clotrimazole (400--600 mg every other day for 12 days) has been used with limited success. Selection of the correct treatment should be based on sensitivity results.

Prognosis
The prognosis for the subsequent fertility of mares with mycotic endometritis is poor. It is suggested that a normal healthy uterus can eliminate mycotic infection.

Metritis
Metritis is the inflammation of the entire thickness of the uterine wall. It occurs when there is massive contamination of the uterus, frequently in association with trauma or retained placenta during foaling. It has a grave prognosis, particularly in heavy horses, since the absorption of toxins from the uterine lumen into the general circulation results in systemic signs including pyrexia, depression, loss of appetite and laminitis. Toxin production is associated with rapid bacterial growth, frequently involving Gram-negative organisms. Treatment involves repeated lavage of the uterus with warm sterile saline (2--3 litres) several times per day until it is free of inflammatory exudates and placental debris. Bacterial growth should be controlled, so as to limit toxin production, with a broad-spectrum antibiotic effective against E. coli, which is invariably present. Supportive therapy with parenteral antibiotics, antihistamines (in cases of retained placenta), oxytocin and intravenous fluid therapy is indicated in many cases.

Systemic signs such as pulse rate and mucous membrane colour are used to monitor the response to therapy in conjunction with examination of the uterine fluid.

Despite all efforts, some mares die due to toxaemia or irreversible changes in the foot following laminitis such as pedal-bone rotation.

 

 

References:

Adams, G. P. and Ginther, O. J. (1989) J. Amer. Vet. Med. Assn, 194, 372.
Allen, W. E. (1991) Vet. Rec., 128, 593.
Allen, W. E. and Pycock, J. F. (1988) Vet. Rec., 122, 489.
Allen, W. E. and Pycock, J. F. (1989) Vet. Rec., 125, 298.
Allen, W. R. (1993) Equine Vet. J., 25, 90.
Asbury, A. C. (1992) Equine Vet. J., 24, 416.
Evans, M. J., Hamer, J. M., Gason, L. M. and Irvine, C. H. G. (1986) Theriogenology, 26, 37.
Farrely, B. Y. and Mullaney, P. E. (1964) Ir. Vet. J., 18, 201.
Ginther, O. J. and Pierson, R. A. (1984) Theriogenology, 21, 505.
Pycock, J. F. (1994a) Equine Vet. Educ., 6, 132.
Pycock, J. F. (1994b) Equine Vet. Educ., 6, 36.
Pycock, J. F. (1994c) Proc. 40th Ann. Conv. Amer. Assn. Equine Pract., p. 19.
Pycock, J. F. and Newcombe, J. R. N. (1996a) Equine Practice18, 19-23.
Pycock, J. F. and Newcombe, J. R. N. (1996b) Veterinary Record 138, 320-323.
Ricketts, S. W. and Mackintosh, M. E. (1987) J. Reprod. Fertil. Suppl., 35, 343.